In ancient Rome, human being would turn to the auguries to analyze the indications of nature prior to important events, specifically on the night of battle.

You are watching: Hawk vs eagle who would win

Special priests, known as augurs, would look tasiilaq.nete the flight and behaviour of bird to build their prognostications.


The characteristics of the Brown Goshawk align particularly well through the traits of the team trotting the end onto the MCG this Saturday.

With countless a nervous footy fan sweating on the result of Saturday's match between Hawthorn and also West Coast, it may be time to dust off the augurs' robes and look tasiilaq.nete the skies to answer the age-old question, "In the wild, that would victory in a fight in between an eagle and a hawk?"

First, a pair of definition issues. Australia has actually three varieties of eagles, if you include the White-bellied Sea-Eagle, which the true raptor-nerd will allude out is in a different genus tasiilaq.nete the 'true' eagles.


Wedge-tailed Eagles are large solid birds that soar high over and swoop down to take it their food - an apt description for the tall wood of West Coast.

This sort of pedantry is why that is finest to stop these civilization at Grand final barbecue.

It also explains why castle don't have actually a girlfriend.

The largest and also most widespread of this is the Wedge-tailed Eagle.

And when Australians regularly refer to any kind of bird of food as a 'hawk' we don't actually have any varieties with that certain name, as well as the sparrowhawks and goshawks. (Pronounced 'goss' as in norm Goss, 1978 Hawthorn Premiership player, no 'gosh' together in "Gosh, awkward does not begin to explain how i feel gift stuck beside you in ~ this Grand last barbecue.")


Surprisingly, the features of both the Wedge-tailed Eagle and also the Brown Goshawk, the most usual of the Aussie hawks, align specifically well with the properties of the 2 sides trotting the end onto the MCG on Saturday afternoon.

The Wedgie sits atop the food chain. They room big, hard birds that soar high over and swoop under to take their prey – an apt descriptor because that the tall wood of West Coast, mockery Kennedy, Jack Darling and of course, Nic Nat.

While substantially smaller, the goshawk is sleeker; a fast flier that relies on guile and stealth to strike its prey – think the likes that Rioli, Hill, and Puopolo.

But that would success in really fight? follow to the birdwatchers' bible, the Handbook the Australian, brand-new Zealand and also Antarctic birds (HANZAB), which collates the data of thousands of bird studies, the continues to be of hawks have been discovered in eagles' nests, however not angry versa.

However there is a caveat to this. If HANZAB shows that in west Australia Brown Goshawks were prey items the the eagle, no examine in Victoria recorded any predation of hawks by eagles. Perhaps even in the bird world, over there is together a point as residence ground advantage.

Three weeks ago in the Qualifying last the hawks were well and truly plucked through the Eagles in Perth however on their house turf, the hawk deserve to be a ferocious defender the its territory. Plenty of a birdwatcher will have witnessed a pair of goshawks successfully see turn off a Wedgie that was foolhardy enough to cruise into the airspace over a goshawk nesting site.

This walk not mean that eagles don't travel well. While castle are greatly territorial, one Wedge-tailed Eagle was tracked in a 2013 study travelling as much as 15,000 km across Western Australia. Take trip takes considerably less the a toll fee on an eagle than a goshawk as the eagle's broader wings mean they deserve to ride the hot air thermals effortlessly and also efficiently.

Saturday's temperature will be the highest possible for any type of Grand Final because 1987, something that would show up to suit those thermal-riding eagles. In their recent State that Australia's birds Report, BirdLife Australia detailed a significant decline in populations of birds of prey across the whole arid zone that Australia.

The Brown Goshawk had one of the most significant declines if Wedgie numbers to be tasiilaq.netparatively stable.

Much has actually been noted of the to tasiilaq.netpare youthfulness the the current Eagles side.

Yet once it concerns birds of prey, youth may not it is in an advantage. That takes substantial skill tasiilaq.nete hunt relocating prey, and the mortality price of young, inexperienced bird is far greater than wily maturation birds, for this reason in this, Hawthorn may have the advantage.

If any of these auspices don't convince, how about the demeanour that coaches?

Anyone who has actually tasiilaq.nete throughout a Wedgie sitting on a carcass on one outback road have the right to attest they are unruffled and literally unflappable together you wait because that them to decision to paris off.

See more: The Pact Book Summary For Chapters 12, General Overview

A characteristic attribute of the Brown Goshawk is a permanently furrowed brow.

Remind girlfriend of anyone? i am suspect that on close investigate you might well uncover several holes punched in the wall surfaces of a goshawk's nest.