Illustprice the enhanced use of grants-in-assist in administering national plans. Demonstrate the distinctions between categorical grants and also block grants. Examine the strategic objectives of nationwide and also state plan machines in advocating the use of block versus categorical grants.Describe the causes and aftermath of raised federal help to the says in recent years.

You are watching: What is the difference between block grants and revenue sharing

Federalism and the Politics of Grants-in-Aid

Due to the fact that the New Deal, the national federal government has actually played an enhancing function in encouraging and also even coercing states to provide federal policies. Central to this evolving connection has actually been the federal government’s use of grants-in-assist to encourage states’ participation in implementing federal plans.


Increases in federal grant-in-assist outlays throughout the second fifty percent of the twentieth century exemplify the boosted function of the national government in the federal balance of power. Federal grants have watched a further twofold increase considering that 2000.

Political actors in the national government create these grant programs with differing degrees of flexibility and also discretion provided to state governments.

Categorical Grants

Categorical grants are federal grants provided to state and also neighborhood federal governments to encourage their teamwork in implementing specific objectives and programs.

These grants offer less adaptability to state federal governments than block grants.Federal officials location significant restrictions on says that accept grants and are quite specific about just how funds are to be spent in certain policy “categories.”

Block Grants

Block grants are federal grants-in-help that allow states considerable discretion (within wide limits) about how the funds will be spent.

These give greater flexibility to state political actors to tailor programs to the state’s specific demands than do categorical grants.The federal government areas few constraints, allowing states to spend funds within wide programmatic areas.

The Politics of Grants-in-Aid: Devolution

When the Republicans took control of Congress after the 1994 elections, their “Contract via America” sought to “devolve” regulate of many type of federal programs to the claims, frequently by replacing existing categorical approve programs via block provide programs. Two examples of this technique are welfare recreate and crime plan.

Ddevelopment in Welfare Reform

The Republicans reput the federal Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) entitlement welfare regimen via Temporary Aid for Needy Families (TANF), which offered block grants to state governments to redevelop welfare.

AFDC: The Federal Role

Federally administered welfare entitlement routine. National federal government imposes requirements and also needs. Federal assistance is an continuous entitlement.

TANF: Increased State Power

Block grants to says to administer help to the poor. States are complimentary to tailor program and also impose included restrictions on recipients. States suppose recipients to move off welfare on a state-established schedule.

Dadvancement in Crime Policy

With the Taking Back Our Streets Act, the Republicans reinserted the specific programs and grants to state and local federal governments that defined the Clinton administration’s crime bill via block grants to states, enabling them to fight crime as they experienced fit.

1994 Crime Bill

Clinton bill: Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994. About $10 billion in grants for certain crime manage and social programs. States should complement 25 percent of federal funds.

Taking Back Our Streets Act

Contract through America’s crime provisions: Taking Back Our Streets Act of 1995. About $10 billion in block grants to states to accomplish basic crime difficulties. States must enhance 10 percent of federal funds.

Analyzing the Rationality Principle

The Rationality Principle: all political behavior has a function. All political actors communicate in instrumental acts designed to further their individual goals.

See more: How Much Is A Box Of Half Dollars By, Bank Roll Indiana Us Half Dollar Coins Mixed Lots

Answer the complying with questions:

State policy maker goals: How does the usage of block grants assist state policy machines to fulfill their individual plan and also political goals?2. Federal plan maker goals: How does the use of categorical grants help federal policy equipments regulate the policy tasks of state and regional federal governments and also benefit federal policy makers politically?

Evaluating the Policy Principle

The Policy Principle: political outcomes are the products of individual choices and institutional actions.

Answer the adhering to questions:

Welfare reform: How might says use or abuse the adaptability provided them under the TANF block grants routine in addressing troubles connected through poverty and welfare?4. Crime legislation: Consider the distinctions in the crime difficulties of Illinois, The golden state, and New York (each of which encounters considerable challenges via violent crime), on the one hand, versus North Dakota, Kansas, and New Hampshire (more rural states), on the various other. What result does establishing a dominion permitting says greater adaptability to attend to crime have on plan making?

One Step Further…

Explaining the Continuing Controversy over Federal Aid

Answer the following questions:

The textbook discusses Republican President George W. Bush’s No Child Left Behind education regulation, which has actually been controversial as some states have intimidated to opt out. Unprefer the Republideserve to proposals of the 1990s, why can President Shrub have promoted an enhancing federal duty in education?6. The figure at the beginning of this exercise mirrors a far-reaching boost in federal grants-in-aid beginning in 2009. What is the resource of this rise and in what means has actually it connected a much more regulated style of federalism?

Submit to Gradebook:
First Name: Please enter your first name
Last Name: Please enter your last name
Your Email Address: Please enter your email address
Your Professor"s Email Address: Please enter your professor"s email address