In the acceptance letter bother Potter got from Hogwarts, the 2nd page has a perform of needs for the start of school. At the bottom the the letter the states:

PARENTS space REMINDED THAT an initial YEARS space NOT permitted THEIR very own BROOMSTICK

And yet, really early top top in his an initial year, bother Potter is gifted a Nimbus 2000 through the head the his home Professor McGonagall. This no doubt make Harry Potter the only very first year student to be allowed their own broom.

Seems come me that McGonagall was intentionally breaking the rule to advantage her very own house, which seems unethical.


*

In Sorcerer"s Stone, it is defined that one-of-a-kind provisions were made to permit Harry to have actually a broomstick.

You are watching: Who gives harry the nimbus 2000

"Potter"s been sent a broomstick, Professor," stated Malfoy quickly.

"Yes, yes, that"s right," claimed Professor Flitwick, beaming at Harry. "Professor McGonagall told me all about the distinct circumstances, Potter. And also what model is it?"

"A Nimbus 2 Thousand, sir."

Sorcerer"s Stone - page 165 - united state Hardcover


*

*

As Kevin noted, harry was provided a one-of-a-kind exemption. From publication 1:

"He"s simply the construct for a Seeker, too," said Wood, now walking about Harry and staring in ~ him. "Light -- speedy -- we"ll have actually to acquire him a kind broom, Professor -- a Nimbus two Thousand or a Cleansweep Seven, I"d say."

"I candlestick speak come Professor Dumbledore and see if us can"t bend the first-year rule. Sky knows, we need a much better team than last year. Flattened in that last complement by Slytherin, i couldn"t watch Severus Snape in the challenge for weeks...." < this to be Prof. McGonagall speak - DVK >


*

When McGonagall was telling Wood about Harry (or somewhere very close to that), she said she"d speak to Dumbledore around getting an exemption for him.

"He"s just the build for a Seeker, too," said Wood, currently walking around Harry and staring in ~ him. "Light -- speedy -- we"ll have actually to get him a kind broom, Professor -- a Nimbus two Thousand or a Cleansweep Seven, I"d say."

"I chandelier speak to Professor Dumbledore and see if we can"t bending the first-year rule. sky knows, we need a better team 보다 last year. Flattened in that last complement by Slytherin, i couldn"t look at Severus Snape in the challenge for weeks..."


*

I think the exception was to join the team, and I think the is implied that the broomstick is because that Quidditch only, and also not for use external these times. The course, the would have needed to practice on his own at times.

IIRC, this is not clearly stated, however, ns think that Harry utilizing it because that his very own purposes would have actually been thought about breaching the rules.

Yes, McGonagall did rest the rule by acquiring Harry into the team, yet had this agreed. Component of this would seem to be him obtaining a broom to use.


The rule says that an initial years are without doubt not enabled to carry their own broomsticks, yet I think in Harry"s situation this dominance is bent due to the fact that he was the an initial first year student in a century to play quidditch. Maybe the "no broom" preeminence is for very first year students due to the fact that they"re not selected because that the quidditch team it rotates the 2nd year at hogwarts (as also mentioned through Ron).Hope the made sense? O.o


The dominance is many likely applied because an initial years cannot regulate brooms, wherein as harry was very competent, therefor permitting an exemption because that the rule.


Thanks for contributing response to science Fiction & Fantasy ridge Exchange!

Please be certain to answer the question. Carry out details and also share your research!

But avoid

Asking because that help, clarification, or responding to various other answers.Making statements based upon opinion; earlier them increase with references or an individual experience.

See more: How Many Goldfish Can Goldfish Live In A 1 Gallon Tank (With Pictures)

To discover more, view our advice on writing good answers.


article Your prize Discard

By click “Post her Answer”, friend agree come our terms of service, privacy policy and also cookie plan


Not the answer you're spring for? Browse various other questions tagged harry-potter or questioning your own question.


does it rest a rule for a an initial year come play Quidditch because that his/her house team, or is it simply tradition?
site design / logo design © 2021 ridge Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Rev2021.9.27.40309


her privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, friend agree stack Exchange can store cookie on your device and disclose info in accordance through our Cookie Policy.